River5 min read

When should a club declare catch-and-release?

Low water, warm nights, a committee that has to decide. Where catch-and-release helps, where it quietly kills fish, and how a reading changes the call.

By Alex Baker, Tadpole

Every summer there is a week when a club committee has to make a call it is not equipped to make. The river is low, the nights are warm, somebody has seen fish stacked in the deep pool below the bridge, and the question arrives by text: should we ask members to stop?

Most clubs answer it on a hunch. Some do nothing and hope. Some declare catch-and-release and feel they have done the responsible thing. That last one is the answer we want to look at, because it is sometimes right and sometimes the worst of the three.

What catch-and-release is for

Catch-and-release is a stock decision. It says: we would like these fish to still be here next year, so put them back. It is the right call when the river is fishable but the population is under pressure, and the pressure is the fishing itself. A low, clear river in June where every fish in the pool can be seen and caught twice is exactly that. So is the run-up to spawning. So is a water that has had a bad year and needs a season off.

In those conditions a fish played quickly, kept in the water and released will almost always recover. The club keeps its members on the bank, keeps its permit income, and keeps its fish.

What it is not for

Catch-and-release is not a heat decision, and the two get confused because they arrive in the same week.

Warm water holds less oxygen. Above roughly 19 to 20°C a trout or salmon is already under strain, and below about 6 mg/L of dissolved oxygen it has little in reserve. A fish played to exhaustion in those conditions needs a burst of oxygen to recover, and there is none spare. It swims off, it looks fine, and it dies out of sight an hour later. We wrote about the numbers in more detail in what a dissolved oxygen reading tells you.

So in a hot spell, declaring catch-and-release is not the safe option. It is the option that kills fish invisibly while everyone feels good about it. The safe option is to stop, and the second safest is to fish only at dawn, when the water is at its coolest and the oxygen at its highest.

A ladder, not a switch

The committees that handle this well do not have a single rule. They have a ladder, and they know which rung they are on.

Normal. Fish, keep within the limits.

Voluntary catch-and-release. The river is low or the stock is thin. Ask members to return fish. Most will.

Mandatory catch-and-release. Same conditions, but the club needs it to be a rule rather than a request, usually because visitors or day-permit anglers are involved.

Dawn only. Water temperature is climbing past the high teens. Fishing is allowed until the sun is on the water and not after. This is the rung most clubs skip, and it is the one that saves fish.

Closed. Dissolved oxygen is low, temperature is high, fish are stacked in the pools. Nobody fishes. Permits stop selling. The club says so on its website and on the gate.

The point of the ladder is that each step has a trigger, and the trigger is something you can see or measure, not a feeling.

How a reading changes the conversation

For years the trigger at our club was a phone call from whoever had been at the river last. That person was usually right, but the committee could not say why, and it could not say when to reopen.

We built a monitor for our own stretch of the Boyne, after a commercial system was quoted at €26,000 and the grant to buy it was refused. It reads dissolved oxygen, temperature and level every few minutes and the committee can see the readings from a phone.

What changed was not the decision. It was the argument. "Oxygen has been under six since Tuesday and the water hit twenty-one yesterday afternoon" ends a committee discussion that "it looked bad on Sunday" would have kept going for an hour. It also tells the club when to reopen, which nobody used to know, so closures dragged on out of caution and members grumbled.

The other thing it changed was the conversation with members. A closure announced with a number and a chart is accepted. A closure announced with "the committee has decided" is argued with.

If you have no monitor

Most clubs do not, and the ladder still works. A cheap thermometer on a string, read at the same pool at the same time each evening, gets you the temperature rung. Fish visibly stacked in the deepest water is the oxygen rung. Level you can read off a bridge pier. Write the readings down, because the value is in the trend, not the number.

And if a club near you has a monitor, ask. The readings from a stretch twenty miles upstream are a better guide than a guess.

What we would say to any committee

Declare catch-and-release when the fishing is the pressure. Close, or go to dawn only, when the water is. Know which one you are doing, and say why, with a number if you have one.


We built Tadpole for our own club and other clubs asked for it. The water quality monitor was built for our own river; the build spec is free to any club that wants to make its own.

Ask us about the water quality monitor →

Encrypted & Isolated
GDPR Built In
Junior Protection
Full Audit Trail
How we protect your data